Cloud baseline
Muse Spark Open, single model via OpenRouter
meta/muse-spark-open · scorer forge-2.0
- Overall
- 0.0877
- Benchmark
- Forge 2.0
- Model build
- 6m 9s
Recorded inference cost
$2.85
From the saved OpenRouter generation billing summary (45 recorded requests). Includes auxiliary model calls made during the build. Scoring reuses the saved build; this amount describes the original inference spend.
Tier breakdown
Each bar is the tier's mean, from 0 to 1 (for E, its mean × the excellence gate). The percentage is the tier's share of the score. Mean × share, added over all tiers, is the tests earned figure below.
Scoring detail
How this score was built
Per-test scorer output, as posted by the app. Expand a section to inspect its tests.
Correctness combines the lowest score for each test across the scoring fixtures; economy measurements use their mean. The combined result can therefore be lower than every individual fixture’s final score. Critical defects reduce the weighted result, followed by the reliability multiplier, before any score cap applies.
The rules behind these numbers: Forge 2.0 requirements, weights and score caps.
The score, step by step
0.3507 tests earned × 1.0000 critical defects × 0.2500 reliability at the floor = 0.0877 final score
tests earned = 0.15 × 0.7395 v1 + 0.2398 v2 (out of 0.85)
v1 = 0.88 × 0.8008 tiers L–A + 0.12 × 0.8697 gate × 0.3333 excellence
Reliability: every tier in the breakdown above, except Excellence, is a group of tests. Each group of tests multiplies the score by 1 − 0.10 × the shortfall of its worst test: by 0.90 when that test fails completely, by 0.95 when it scores 0.5.
- L Lint and bundles: worst test
l_scopes, score 0.5 × 0.9500 - K Platform currency: worst test
k_widget_edit_bridge, score 0.75 × 0.9750 - T Event pipeline: worst test
t_out_of_order, score 0.4286 × 0.9429Already counted in this group: t_event_rows, t_multi_sprint_parse, t_reestimate_followed
- R Reconcile: worst test
r_backfill_complete, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: r_removals_found, r_heal_dropped, r_pagination, r_completes_in_timeout, r_idempotent_rerun
- S Storage: worst test
s_entity_index_used, score 0.9444 × 0.9944 - B Resolvers and permissions: worst test
b_hidden_count, score 0.2222 × 0.9222Already counted in this group: b_comment_adf_as_user
- U UI function: worst test
u_widget_live, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: u_widget_numbers, u_widget_chart, u_widget_edit_config, u_ledger_table, u_ledger_sort, u_llm_explain
- A Rovo: worst test
a_action_result, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: a_action_permissions
- R1 Migration: worst test
r1_progress_visible, score 0 × 0.9000 - R2 Dosing: worst test
r2_person_never_quota_refused, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: r2_background_share, r2_rate_limit_reaction, r2_backfill_complete
- R3 Time limits: worst test
r3_never_killed, score 0.875 × 0.9875Already counted in this group: r3_long_retry_after_deferred
- R4 Changing world: worst test
r4_sprint_close_final, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: r4_move_new_board, r4_field_switch, r4_deleted_history, r4_permission_revoked
- R5 Admin panel: worst test
r5_panel_labels, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: r5_admin_actions_apply, r5_nonadmin_refused
- R6 CI web trigger: worst test
r6_unsigned_no_effect, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: r6_replay_once, r6_status_codes, r6_valid_applies, r6_secret_never_disclosed
- R7 Custom field: worst test
r7_values_fresh, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: r7_writes_accepted
- R8 Forge LLM: worst test
r8_cost_controls, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: r8_failure_handling
- R9 Boot budget: worst test
r9_admin_boot, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: r9_widget_boot, r9_sprint_boot
- R10 Native JQL: worst test
r10_manifest, score 0 × 0.9000Already counted in this group: r10_initial_membership, r10_precomputation_refresh, r10_shared_permissions, r10_empty_and_closed, r10_invalid_arguments
At the floor: the groups multiply to less than 0.25, and together the groups never take the score below 0.25 of what the tests earned, so reliability stays at 0.25. A critical defect still multiplies on top.
v1 is this run's score on the tests carried over from Forge 1.0: 15% of the total. v2 is the requirements R1–R10, each at its share of the score: the other 85%. Critical defects multiply the whole score, and so does each group of tests, by 1 − 0.10 × the shortfall of its worst test.
Excellence gate 0.8697: the average of the 18 conditions below, each counted at the value shown. Green is met in full; red is not, and lowers the gate. The 3 excellence tests are paid in proportion to the gate; together they are 1.8% of the total.
Earned score 0.0877 · No cap applies · Final score 0.0877
Under a cap the final score is min(earned, cap − 0.05 × (1 − earned)): always below the cap, and closer to it the more the run earned. With no cap it is the earned score. Avoiding a cap adds no points.
Forge's own linter reports no errors (warnings cost points), every manifest function bundles and loads, packages resolve at the kit's pins, the manifest rules the linter misses, and only the scopes the app's calls need.
l deployable
1.00lint: 0 errors, every stage reached
l bundles load
1.0010/10 functions bundle, load and export their handler
l lint warnings
1.000 distinct lint warning(s): []
l real packages
1.0010/10 bundles resolve @forge/* at the kit pins only
l manifest rules
1.006/6 manifest rules met:
l scopes
0.50scopes: missing [], extra ['read:application-role:jira', 'read:issue-type:jira']
Current modules and APIs: dashboards:widget with its edit API, the rovo:skill and rovo:mcp wiring, a Forge LLM model the platform lists as active, no /rest/api/3/search, no @forge/api storage, a nodejs22.x or nodejs24.x runtime, the consumer shape, the declared KVS entity, and deploy readiness: a manifest and permissions real Forge would accept and no code predicted to fail there.
k dashboard widget
1.00dashboards:widget 2/2: {'custom_ui_resource': True, 'edit_resource': True}
k widget edit bridge
0.753/4 board picks reached the dashboard through the widget edit API (updateConfig/onProductSave)
k rovo skill
1.00rovo:skill 7/7:
k current apis
1.00current APIs 5/5:
k consumer shape
1.00consumer shape 3/3
k entity declared
1.00entities with a sprint-partitioned, ranged index: ['scope-change', 'scope-ledger', 'sprint-issue']
k v2 surfacesdiagnostic, no weight
1.00v2 surfaces declared: ['jira:adminPage', 'webtrigger', 'scope-ledger']
k rovo mcp
1.00rovo:mcp 4/4:
k llm model current
1.0012 LLM call(s); model ids list() does not return: []; llm module with claude: True
k manifest semantics
1.00deploy readiness, manifest + permissions: 17 rules checked, none failing here
k runtime risks
1.00deploy readiness, predicted runtime failures: 12 rules checked, none failing here
Issue updates flow trigger to queue to consumer: one ledger row per change under duplicate, reordered, dropped and concurrent deliveries, multi-sprint changelog values, re-estimates followed, Retry-After honoured, no user context in background work.
t trigger handoff
1.001023/1023 deliveries handed off correctly
t event rows
0.8742worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3c04f61f28a4a511): event rows: 132/170 exact (precision 1.00, recall 0.78)
t no double count
1.00every change holds at most one ledger row in every phase (duplicated deliveries included); 23 concurrent group(s) raced (independent 14, same-event 5, same-issue 4)
t out of order
0.4286worst of 3 scoring sites (seed d031c3ee22136508): permuted deliveries: 5/11 rows exact, 1/3 sprints with oracle numbers
t multi sprint parse
0.9847worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3aaa6d6b73d37669): 129/131 multi-id Sprint changes recorded exactly
t reestimate followed
0.50worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3aaa6d6b73d37669): 3/6 re-estimated sprints show the oracle numbers
t retry after honoured
1.00InvocationError retryAfter 30s >= 30s
t no user in async
1.00background work is asApp only
The first scheduled run starts the backfill of every change since each active sprint started, removals included; later runs heal what the event stream missed and a run with nothing new writes nothing; they page through results in each endpoint's own style, never retry before Retry-After and finish inside the module timeout, queue continuations included.
r backfill complete
0.000/130 historical changes v1 never recorded, recorded one virtual hour after the upgrade (the backfill is dosed; v1 rows are R1's, at 2 h)
r removals found
0.000/24 removed-to-backlog changes found
r heal dropped
0.25worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3c04f61f28a4a511): 1/4 dropped changes healed exactly once; 0 other row(s) added
r pagination
0.9792worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3c04f61f28a4a511): 47/48 reads the site served in two or more pages walked to their end through the cursors the site offered (/rest/agile/1.0/board 15/15, /rest/agile/1.0/board/{id}/sprint
r rate limit
1.00run 1 (backfill) request 2: waited 2.2 virtual s in-invocation; run 1 (backfill) continuation page: waited 2.2 virtual s in-invocation; run 2 (hour-1) request 2: waited 2.2 virtual s in-invocation
r as app
1.00169/169 Jira calls of the scheduled runs and their queue continuations asApp (scheduled 169)
r completes in timeout
0.8757/8 invocations of the scheduled runs and their queue continuations inside their module timeout (scheduled 8)
r idempotent rerun
0.50worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3c04f61f28a4a511): 3 ledger write(s) (scope-ledger) on a no-change run over 355 rows
Forge KVS with the storage scope, ledger reads through the declared entity index in change-time order, no KVS limit errors.
s storage scope
1.00KVS used, no 403 from the KVS proxy
s entity index used
0.944417/18 ledger reads are entity queries on a declared index
s index order
1.006/6 tables list changes in change-time order
s limits
1.00no KVS limit errors
Every invoked resolver exists and answers structured errors, nobody sees changes to issues they cannot browse (not on screen, not in an LLM prompt, not in a Realtime payload), the hidden-change count is right, and each click posts exactly one ADF comment as the viewer.
b invoke contract
1.0052/52 invokes returned a defined, structured result; a Jira 500 on sprintLedger's read: handled
b no permission leak
1.00no hidden key, summary or change id reached a person
b hidden count
0.22224/18 hidden counts equal the oracle
b comment adf as user
0.50worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3aaa6d6b73d37669): 6/12 comments are ADF as the viewer naming key, sprint and creep; ['24855 status 201 via user', '24963 status 201 via user', '27265 status 201 via user']
b comment exactly once
1.0012 click/double-click gesture(s), none posted more than one comment
b realtime payload clean
1.00191/191 realtime payloads hold sprint ids only
The dashboard widget's numbers and chart, its board choice saved through the host, live updates through Forge Realtime, the sprint action's ledger table, sorting, issue links, comment flow, the Forge LLM explanation, close and not-started states.
u widget loadsdiagnostic, no weight
1.004/8 configured widget views render a sprint with its numbers
u widget numbers
0.50worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3aaa6d6b73d37669): widget numbers: 4.00/8 views exact (sprints by startDate, four §1 numbers each)
u widget chart
0.50worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3aaa6d6b73d37669): 4/8 charts on one linear scale within 1px; ['no single svg[data-testid=chart]', 'no single svg[data-testid=chart]']
u widget edit config
0.70edit/config 7/10: pick0_view_shows_board, pick0_reopen_pressed, second_instance_own_board
u ledger table
0.7806worst of 3 scoring sites (seed d031c3ee22136508): ledger tables: 4.68/6 exact (rows, cells, default order)
u ledger sort
0.8333worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3aaa6d6b73d37669): 15/18 at-toggle states ordered with aria-sort (6 after another sort was active)
u issue router
1.006/6 issue keys open /browse/<KEY> through the Forge router
u comment flow
1.0032/32 comment-flow steps right (select, one comment and a success flag per click and double click, forbidden error flag, modal works)
u modal close
1.006/6 close clicks reached bridge close
u not started
1.00future sprint shows not-started only
u widget live
0.00moved sprints showing the new numbers live 0/1; gate failed: subscribed; 0 idle invoke(s)
u llm explain
0.9565worst of 3 scoring sites (seed d031c3ee22136508): explain 22/23 over 5 scripted answers: 1:digits:every_number_is_a_ledger_number
Atlassian design tokens with 4.5:1 contrast in light and dark, a painted surface, no Content Security Policy violations or console errors, and the widget readable at 380 px wide.
v theme tokens
1.0029/29 surfaces themed with --ds-text* at >= 4.5:1
v dark mode
1.0029/29 surfaces paint a --ds-surface* background in their mode
v csp clean
1.000 CSP violation(s), 0 failed asset request(s)
v console clean
1.000 console/page error(s) on nominal scenarios: []
v widget sizes
1.004/4 widget sizes without horizontal overflow, every sprint visible, no number clipped
The get-sprint-scope action returns exact numbers and the visible changes for the invoking person, returns errors instead of throwing, and the skill's SKILL.md tells the agent how to use it.
a action result
0.000/5 active sprints answered exactly
a action errors
1.002/2 bad sprintId inputs return {error} without throwing
a action permissions
0.000/12 per-person answers list exactly what that person may browse
a skill instructions
1.00SKILL.md body 5/5: result fields named ['sprintName', 'committed', 'added', 'removed', 'creepPercent', 'hiddenChanges', 'changes']
Few Jira requests in the first scheduled run and per relevant change in triggers and consumers, and surfaces that paint after one round trip — paid only in proportion to the excellence gate.
e reconcile economy
0.00mean over 3 scoring sites: backfill incomplete — economy is not credited on unfinished work
e event economy
0.00mean over 3 scoring sites: event rows inexact — economy is not credited on unfinished work
e ui round trips
1.00mean over 3 scoring sites: round trips before first paint: {'widget-view': 0, 'widget-edit': 1, 'sprint-action': 1}
Every v1 row moves to the new scope-ledger entity exactly once, with its change id and time, while events keep flowing and across invocation limits, within 2 virtual hours of the upgrade, with its progress in the admin panel; v1's entity stays intact.
r1 v1 rows migrated
1.00h2: 59 of 59 v1 rows in scope-ledger with the source attributes recorded by the probe
r1 v1 rows intact
1.00all 59 v1 source rows intact; 59 final copies preserve recorded v1 attributes at every observed checkpoint
r1 events during migration
1.0048 of 48 changes made while the migration ran are in scope-ledger at the end
r1 progress visible
0.00required app surface absent: jira:adminPage as a UI Kit panel (the migration progress lives in the admin panel) — NOT_NATIVE: module 'scope-admin-page' (jira:adminPage) is not UI Kit: it has no `render: native`
On a site of about 1,000 issues, background work stays inside its share of the 2,400-point hour, no person-facing request meets a quota 429, and Retry-After and RateLimit-Reason (quota, burst, per-issue write) decide every retry; the backfill still completes.
r2 background share
0.60worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3aaa6d6b73d37669): 6 of 10 hours kept background within 70 % (1680 points; the contract default; the probe recorded no change); busiest hour 2572; over in hours 3, 5, 6 (+1); mandatory fiel
r2 person never quota refused
0.0014 of 462 person-facing requests refused for quota (e.g. /rest/agile/1.0/sprint/{sprintId}, /rest/agile/1.0/sprint/{sprintId}, /rest/agile/1.0/sprint/{sprintId} (+11))
r2 rate limit reaction
0.1395worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3c04f61f28a4a511): 6 of 43 429s answered by their reason (quota: all background paused; burst: the endpoint; per-issue: the issue); broken: jira-quota-tenant-based at 1793277065411 ms: 35 r
r2 backfill complete
0.000 of 130 pre-upgrade changes v1 never recorded are in scope-ledger, right; wrong time/board/estimate 130 (e.g. ('1442411', '808'), ('1442434', '808'), ('1442461', '808') (+127))
Work longer than one invocation continues in the next, no function waits past its limit (a long Retry-After is handed back, not waited out), and a killed invocation leaves no duplicate.
r3 never killed
0.8757 of 8 functions never exceeded their limit; killed: reconcile (1 of 8)
r3 long retry after deferred
0.9565worst of 3 scoring sites (seed d031c3ee22136508): 22 of 23 invocations handed a Retry-After longer than their limit stopped and resumed later (results: killed, ok, retry); waited it out and were killed: inv-01335-cc79d9
r3 no duplicate rows
1.00every (changeId, sprintId) appears once at each of 7 checkpoints; 23 concurrent group(s) raced (independent 14, same-event 5, same-issue 4)
Sprints close, issues move to another board's sprint, a board's estimation field changes, issues are deleted and a person loses browse permission while the app runs; the ledger and every view come out right.
r4 sprint close final
0.00worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3c04f61f28a4a511): 0 of 1 closed sprints kept exactly their final ledger; sprint 977: 5 rows gone (e.g. ('1452791', '977'), ('1453102', '977') (+3))
r4 move new board
0.000 of 17 cross-board moves recorded with the new board's estimate; BILL-182 (1442633): removed row wrong/missing, added row wrong/missing (estimate 0, want 0)
r4 field switch
0.000 of 42 rows after the switch use the new field; 0 of 20 earlier rows keep their estimate; wrong after: ('1453658', '1026'), ('1455633', '1026'), ('1455746', '1026') (+39); wrong before: ('1447402', '1026'), ('1447531',
r4 deleted history
0.00worst of 3 scoring sites (seed 3aaa6d6b73d37669): 0 of 3 rows of deleted issues kept as history with deleted: true; not flagged ('1493398', '984'), ('1494030', '984'), ('1493398', '1068')
r4 permission revoked
0.00vacuous — precondition unmet: no request after the browse revoke showed any ledger data, so hiding proves nothing
A jira:adminPage built in UI Kit with the contract's controls, and every admin resolver checking Jira's ADMINISTER permission on the server, never trusting the payload.
r5 panel labels
0.00required app surface absent: jira:adminPage as a UI Kit panel — NOT_NATIVE: module 'scope-admin-page' (jira:adminPage) is not UI Kit: it has no `render: native`
r5 admin actions apply
0.00required app surface absent: jira:adminPage as a UI Kit panel — NOT_NATIVE: module 'scope-admin-page' (jira:adminPage) is not UI Kit: it has no `render: native`
r5 nonadmin refused
0.00required app surface absent: jira:adminPage as a UI Kit panel — NOT_NATIVE: module 'scope-admin-page' (jira:adminPage) is not UI Kit: it has no `render: native`
Signed deployment events: a missing or wrong signature, a tampered body or a stale timestamp is refused with no effect, a replay applies once, a valid event records the deployment, and the secret is never disclosed.
r6 unsigned no effect
0.00vacuous — precondition unmet: no valid event had an effect, so a refusal proves nothing
r6 replay once
0.00vacuous — precondition unmet: concurrent pair statuses 401, 401 did not demonstrate one 202 and one 200
r6 status codes
0.505 of 10 cases answered with their status; wrong: valid: 401 (want 202), replay: 401 (want 200) (+2)
r6 valid applies
0.000 of 3 validly signed events accepted (202) and recorded as `Deployed to <env>` on every ledger row of the issues they name; valid: status 401, header-case: status 401 (+1)
r6 secret never disclosed
0.00required app surface absent: jira:adminPage as a UI Kit panel (where the CI secret is rotated) — NOT_NATIVE: module 'scope-admin-page' (jira:adminPage) is not UI Kit: it has no `render: native`
The read-only scope-status field holds committed or added +points for an issue in an active sprint, removed for one that has left an active sprint since that sprint started, and nothing for any other issue, written in bulk through Jira's app field-value API and fresh within the virtual hour.
r7 values fresh
0.00mean over 7 checkpoints; worst h1: 0 of 333 issues right; AUTH-10 None (want committed); AUTH-107 None (want committed)
r7 writes accepted
0.00vacuous — precondition unmet: the app wrote no field value
Tool calls validated against the viewer's sprint scope, back-off on a 429 without Retry-After, answers with no finish reason refused, a 10-minute cache, and the admin's kill switch and daily token budget enforced on the server.
r8 tool call scope
1.002 of 2 manipulated calls respected function and visible sprint scope
r8 failure handling
0.501 of 2 LLM failures handled; unfinished answer content was shown or no error flag appeared
r8 cost controls
0.000 of 3 cache/kill-switch/budget cases met their full outcome; cache did not serve an identical successful answer without a new call, or leaked to another viewer, kill-switch: no admin panel to switch the setting (+1)
The widget and the sprint action each make at most one invoke and load at most 150 KB before their first data paint, with no external origin; the admin page renders after one invoke.
r9 widget boot
0.6667widget-view: 1 invoke(s) before first paint (<= 1), 244622 bytes of JS+CSS (<= 153600), 0 external request(s)
r9 sprint boot
0.6667sprint-modal: 1 invoke(s) before first paint (<= 1), 248321 bytes of JS+CSS (<= 153600), 0 external request(s)
r9 admin boot
0.00required app surface absent: jira:adminPage as a UI Kit panel — NOT_NATIVE: module 'scope-admin-page' (jira:adminPage) is not UI Kit: it has no `render: native`
scopeChanged(sprintId) is a jira:jqlFunction returning native issue predicates from the ledger. Jira shares its precomputed expansion across users, applies each viewer's browse permissions, and keeps the same cached mapping fresh through the documented precomputation update API after changes and reconciliation. Empty, future and closed sprints, IN and NOT IN, and invalid arguments are checked by running actual native JQL.
r10 manifest
0.00scopeChanged manifest declaration does not match the contract
r10 initial membership
0.00scopeChanged manifest declaration does not match the contract
r10 precomputation refresh
0.00scopeChanged manifest declaration does not match the contract
r10 shared permissions
0.00scopeChanged manifest declaration does not match the contract
r10 empty and closed
0.00scopeChanged manifest declaration does not match the contract
r10 invalid arguments
0.00scopeChanged manifest declaration does not match the contract
Graded browser recording
Loading duration…Watch the full graded browser recording at its original speed: the dashboard widget, the sprint action, the not-started sprint and the Forge LLM cases, as the scorer drove them on the run's own seed, the first of the three scoring sites. The test results and screenshots on this page provide the wider evidence. Pause or scrub to inspect a view.
The UI Kit admin panel is not in the recording: it is graded from its component tree.
Drag the timeline to seek. Keyboard: arrow keys move 5 seconds; Home and End jump to the start and end.
SHA-256: 1f8fa23d33c506938d6b54bb211096867f0fa9e562c8f61fe106410f82ca77a7
Screenshots
Pictures from one of the three scoring sites, the one on the run's own seed. The dashboard widget and the sprint action are captured from the built app in a browser during grading. A test keeps the score of its worst site (the excellence measurements keep their mean), so a test can fail on a site these pictures do not show. A detail that opens "worst of …" names the seed of the site the test scored worst on, which can be the pictured one.
Run details
- Model
- meta/muse-spark-open
- Engine events
- 0
- Repair rounds
- 0
- Started
- Oct 19, 2026, 05:23 PM
- Finished
- Oct 19, 2026, 05:49 PM